Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Essay #3

“No Name Woman" is one of the more frequently anthologized sections, and a first chapter of The Woman Warrior. It was written by Maxine Hong Kingston who was born in Stockton, California, in 1940 to Chinese immigrant parents. It encapsulates so many of the ambiguity and complexity, the place of women in traditional Chinese society, and the difficulty of growing up as a Chinese-American. In the story, Kingston talked about the struggle of her aunt who gave into a dangerous sexual passion and then was cast out by her village. It is also the struggle of Kingston herself, who attempts to make sense of her old customs and traditions. Kingston wrote this story base on what her mom told her. “You must not tell anyone,” my mother said, “what I am about to tell you.” It was kind of a secret of her family, and she was conflicted between private and public the story. At the end, she did public a story. I think Kingston should have kept story “No Name Woman” a secret, and the story shouldn’t be public.
“In China her father had one sister who killed herself. She jumped into the family well. We say that your father has all brothers because it is as if she had never been born.” That’s how Kingston known that she had an aunt. Kingston’s family found a young man in the next village, and was same her aunt’s age to be her husband. The night she first saw him, he had sex with her. Then he left for America. In 1924, Kingston’s father and his brothers and her grandfather and his brothers and her aunt’s new husband sailed for America, the Gold Mountain. After they had gone for years, suddenly her aunt was pregnant. Her mom revealed, “She could not have been pregnant, you see, because her husband had been gone for years. No one said anything. We did not discuss it. In early summer she was ready to have the child, long after the time when it could have been possible.” Because of Kingston aunt’s husband had gone for so long, so the villagers thought the child was illegitimate. The night that the baby was born, the villagers raided and destroyed her family’s house, and her aunt gave birth in a pigsty. The next morning her mother found her sister-in-law and the baby plugging up the well.

1 comment:

  1. 1. I think Kingston should have kept story “No Name Woman? A secret, and the story shouldn’t be public.

    2. I do not think that you have given a lot of evidence stating why you do not think that this story should have been published. However, you did give lots of citing from the reading. In the next paragraph, try to focus more on the argument.

    3. Refer to answer #2. I know that you are not done yet, therefore most of your critical thinking I not yet stated in your essay.

    4. No, not yet. I do not think that you necessarily need a counter claim because u are focusing on why the story should not have been written about. I would say to just support and back up your reasoning’s on why it should not have been published.

    5. I feel that you have great citing from the reading. Just focus more on the evidence about why it should not have been written about. I feel like I keep repeating myself (so sorry)

    6. Like I said in #4, I would focus more on why you feel that it should not be written about.

    7. I think that so far your essay is looking good. In the next paragraphs explain why you feel that this story should not have been written about and maybe give a personal experience of something that has happened to you in your life that you didn’t want people to know about, but it got out anyway. (just a few ideas.) Good Luck!! = )

    ReplyDelete